Skip to product information
1 of 9

Medium Jewelry Mystery Box

3-4 pieces per box!

Regular price
$22.95 USD
Regular price
Sale price
$22.95 USD
Shipping calculated at checkout.
What types of earring hooks would you like?

This jewelry mystery box could contain any of the jewelry found within our other themed mystery boxes, as well as our original jewelry not found in any other boxes! This extra small box will contain 1 piece, as well as bonus stickers.

Most earrings found in this box dangle, but we do have some studs available. Unfortunately, at this time, we do not have hypoallergic studs. 

Potential Items:

  • Earrings (standard hooks, hypoallergenic, studs, and clip-ons)
  • Necklaces (typically pendants, some lockets and chokers)
  • Rings
  • Bracelets (limited supply)
  • Ear cuffs

If your purchase is a gift for someone, please include occassion in Personalization. 

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews
veranika (Massachusetts, United States)
in love

YESSSS BUY THIS RIGHT NOW!! i am so incredibly happy!!! this exactly what i wanted :’) tysm <3 the jewelry is so beautiful!!!

Lilly Franca (Oklahoma, United States)
Medium/Small Jewelry Mystery Box

I love everything I got in my mystery box I can't pick just one favorite because I think every piece is my favorite.

I will be buying from here again and I will be telling my friends about Boxford Comma.

Paige La Rue (Tennessee, United States)

Medium Jewelry Mystery Box

Anna Keil (Bavaria, Germany)
awesome choice

i purchased the medium jewelry mystery box and even though i only put minor suggestions, they exceeded my expectations so much! I love everything in the box i received a lot and can’t wait to order again!!

Rhiannon Crimmins (California, United States)

Shelley you madwoman (madperson?), your taste is impeccable. I love all the pieces you included (those earrings??? I’m obsessed!!), and I really felt like you took into consideration the personalization note I left.